‘Shepherds of Small Flocks’

By Zoha Waseem

To be honest, I had not heard much about Shahbaz Bhatti before the brutal attack on his life allegedly orchestrated by the Pakistani Taliban on March 2, 2011. I guarantee many Pakistanis were not familiar with his name either. He appeared not to have the popularity and charismatic persona that Salman Taseer had built during his lifetime. To be fair, Bhatti has been acknowledged for all that shortly after succumbing to lethal bullet wounds and breathing his last.

Now, the world knows Shahbaz Bhatti, the protector of minorities; a Christian born to Jacob Bhatti; an outspoken minister who stood against blasphemy laws in Pakistan; another victim of extremism – one of many.

Pakistan’s Christian minority has dealt with its share of injustice and violence. The Gojra incident is still fresh in the minds of most Pakistanis. (In case memories are rusted, it was the day eight Christians were brutally killed in southern Punjab, and their homes torched and looted, based on rumours of alleged blasphemy of the Quran.)

It is no surprise then that minorities in Pakistan are on the run. Ahmedi families of victims of the armed attack on the Ahmedis in Lahore last year have been granted asylum by the Canadian government. Sipah-e-Sahaba and other sectarian organisations have repeatedly targeted Pakistan’s Shias. But little besides drawing room conversations and debate is pursued in response. Much was written following Taseer’s murder but eventually we moved on to fashion weeks, the world cup, political scandals and frustrated young girls ranting on about marriage proposals.

It is indeed time to reconsider our priorities. Where will blasphemy laws take us? I believed Taseer’s murder would be the exception, not the rule. But have the blasphemy laws in Pakistan involuntarily justified murder in the name of religion. And what religion? The extremists within and outside Pakistan are hell-bent on establishing their own version of Islam, their own Caliphate. Anyone deviating or differentiating to their beliefs is labelled a ‘kaafir’, or an ‘apostate’ ruler favouring ‘far enemies’ as recognised by bin Laden and Zawahiri. Anyone supporting these ‘apostate rulers’ are therefore kaafirs as well. All the truly innocent ones who die in the process – well, they’re automatically titled as ‘shaheeds’, guaranteed a place in Heaven. How convenient.

Pakistani Taliban have been preaching, practising, and portraying the most extreme picture of Islam, and especially Islam as it stands in Pakistan. Is there any end in sight or will anyone with a voice and opinion have a gun held to their throat? From an academic point of view, this does appear to be an ideological problem gripping the nation, and in such an extreme situation the ‘might is right’ debate should be reconsidered. Can military power really root out extremism in Pakistan?

Taseer and Bhatti are tragic losses for Pakistan. But will their voices be heard now that they’ve passed or will they just become another figure in history we will tend to forget over time, another name in a text book, another piece of news that fades from the first page to the last and eventually ceases to exist? There will be no other Salman Taseer or Shahbaz Bhatti because fortunately, or unfortunately, human nature can be forgiving and forgetful.

But if cynicism isn’t your forte, then pray the people of Pakistan are not further desensitised to death, destruction, bloodshed, the inhumane taking of lives, and the ‘quagmire’ gripping Pakistan. Only then can a thousand Taseers and Bhattis rise, and a thousand Qadris fall.

I recently read online that someone once asked Shahbaz Bhatti who he was. He replied simply, “I’m the shepherd of a small flock in a big farm.” With shepherds being targeted, will Pakistan’s ‘lost sheep’ find their way?

Zoha Waseem is a post-graduate from King’s College London in ‘Terrorism, Security and Society’.

The views expressed by this blogger do not necessarily reflect the views of Khudi.



Bookmark and Share

7 Responses to “‘Shepherds of Small Flocks’”

  1. Fahad Khan says:

    Can military power really root out extremism in Pakistan? This scourge of extremism and fundamentalism has its roots in the “Afghan Jihad” era when the military dictator Zia pushed this nation into the whirlwind of extremism. It’s highly unlikely that the same institution and mindset would do anything to wipe it out.

  2. Rana Abdul Aziz says:

    I share the gloom and doubt expressed in the piece. No one can deny that Pakistan is in a bad way. What I fail to understand is how do we know at this point in time who did the cruel act. This particular one. I am not et al suggesting that a segment of the society ain’t twisted in its outlook. And yes, there are assassins available in the country who will carry out such brutal acts on cash. But what evidence do we have to claim with any certainty that it is TTP, ISI, or CIA or whatever this time around. I need to know how this works. How do we place responsibility of an incident on one organisation or the other. Really need help on that.

  3. Saeed Hamad Al Neaimi says:

    Very well written piece, i’m proud to have tutored this student, that has managed to blossom into such an extraodinary writter

  4. Zeeshan says:

    Zoha, fantastic piece! May you go far with your gift. We need it all too badly in Pakistan.

  5. Zoha Waseem says:

    Many thanks for reading and commenting everyone.

    @ Rana: I will soon be posting another blog that may address your questions. Stay tuned.

  6. I’ve lately started a blog, the information you provide on this website has helped me tremendously. Thank you for all of your time & work.

  7. Les Seachord says:

    Hi there, was searching through the net for a bit of information and came across your page. I am very impressed by the info that you have posted on this blog. It tells me how good you understand this topic. Bookmarked this site, and will be back soon. Thanks for great info.

Leave a Reply